Well lights were just coming on this morning and a small piece of coral still remains.... hopefully it is just receded and not devoured beyond repair. I will let it have day under lights and post pic of what it looks like tonight. I have done a bit of digging myself and pencil urchins typically do not eat corals but it has been know to happen. Although its not fully reef safe I have never had any issues with him before eating any corals, now he has been known to decorate himself with one and carry it around the tank proudly showing off his bling. Currently I think he is on probation but if he violates I think I will have to sentence him to prison in the sump or relocate to new home.