Dave,
Knowing where you are at and your water system I'm pretty confident it is your water pressure.
That true, your on a well right?
For my system, no difference in volume with our without the valve.
Do you have an auto top off? If not, get rid of the shut off, and install a valve before the unit, and on the outlet side. That way you can cut the water into the unit. My Valve isn't the greatest, and sometimes with changes in the house water pressure it turns the unit on.